The main problem of (6 school) divisions in the B12 is :
a) All TX teams together or not, good or bad - potential controversy here.
b) If split naturally west-east the "Black and Blue" division will be the West (TT, OKSt, BYU, TCU, BYU and UH) and the "Lesser Than" division will be the East.
c) If 2 regular divisions then winners of each will be in ConfChampGame. Maybe
not the two best teams that year.
Here's the solution of divisions in the B12:
Football only: Four "triads" for scheduling only. Optimal geography for the respective division members. These divisions don't exit in the standings.
SW Division (1)
TCU
Baylor
Houston
Western Division (2)
BYU
TXTech
OkieSt
Midwest Division (3)
IowaSt
KU
K-State
Eastern (time zone) Division (4)
WVU
Cinci
U Central Fla
8 B12 games annually, 4 home, 4 away, toggle biannually, per team.
Each division provides 2 "rivals" and both are geographically optimal within the conference. Each year one home, one away.
Each division plays 2 others in 2 year cycles (home/away) for 6 games. 3 home, 3 away each season.
With 8 in-conf games per year, minimize "beating up each other" weakening our collective records and poll standings. Use the SEC "strategy" to game the polls for the entire conference.
There should be ample inventory of 48 conference games for TV broadcast with 12 teams and the respective $$$.
This also frees up every B12 team for an extra OOC game that can be dedicated to a annual home & away non-conference "rival" or geographically-near school.
(TCU:SMU, IwSt:Iowa, BYU:Utah, UCF:South FL, Houston:Rice, WV
itt-Kentucky-VaTech, OkSt:OU, KU:Mizzou, K-State/Nebraska?, Cinci:Lousiville- Memphis, TT:UTEP/NM/Colo/ColSt., etc.)
Then the 3 other OOC can be home bodybag (warm up, first game), a decent mid-level FBS team and a "stretch" FBS more top tier matchup. The respective ADs can do what they want with these 3 games as to competitive level and geographic area. This could give the B12 more nationwide exposure in the aggregate.
Year 1 & Year 2: (for home & away toggle)
Div. 1 plays Div2 & Div3, Div2 plays Div1 & Div4, Div 3 plays Div1 and 4, Div 4 plays Div2 and Div3.
Re-scramble for Years 3 & 4:
1 plays 2 & 4, 2 plays 1 & 3, 3 plays 2 & 4, and 4 plays 1 & 3.
Re-scramble again for Years 5 & 6:
1 plays 3 & 4, 2 plays 3 & 4 , 3 plays 1 & 2, 4 plays 1 & 2
This model is more dynamic than the quad system we had in the WAC back in the '90s. It's "everyone playing everyone" and for the Conference to be truly a conference with great inter-school/team familiarity/exposure/integration.
Standings will be conference-wide. No Division standings. Top 2 teams go to
Conference Championship game. Since a tie could exist for #2 there must be clearly thought out rules to adjudicate that outcome.
Never play 9 conf. games unless the SEC does so.