Zubaz
Member
Here's the same shot, with a transparent line along the sideline for reference. His foot is pretty clearly over, there's even some over the line.
Now, that's a fairly low resolution shot, and obviously the replay isn't photoshopping an image for reference. I think from an objective standpoint they got it right. Key word, "think". The question is whether they made the right decision given the information they had at the time and had enough "indisputable" evidence at the time.