Zubaz
Member
Jake Fromm is the only real example here.While I agree that this should be healthy Kenny Hill's team, I don't believe your ratio.
AggyFootball, RGMe, BM, RapeyKingCrabJameis, Jake Fromm State Farm.
Jameis redshirted a year, then was EJ Manuel's backup before starting his third year out of high school. Manziel redshirted in 2011 before starting in 2012. Baker Mayfield was bad and ended up hurt / benched his Freshman year, sat a year, and wasn't a true star until three years out of high school. RG3 put up some nice stats, but on a 4-8 team that was nothing special, sat the 2009 season out with injury before coming in to his own in 2010.
There are very very few examples of a true Freshman coming in and lighting it up against top flight competition, for the reasons that @Deep Purple mentioned.