In today's Austin American Statesman,Suzanne Halliburton has a column reviewing the "Fab 55" recruits from 2006. It was a mixed report card on how valuable they turned out to be come 2010. i will not quote the article, only summarize in my own words:
Of the four first round NFL picks, only one -- Stafford (QB from GA) -- was on the Statesman's 2006 list of the top 55.
TCU's Jerry Hughes wasn't a member (along with Okung, and Crabtree).
Of her Top Ten recruits based on their productivity and value as of 2010, TCU's Hughes was her No. 4 pick, and Andy Dalton was her No. 6. Sergio Kindle was her No 5 ...and the only Longhorn in the ten.
While Sergio kindle (No. 1 on the original 55 listing) produced well, the column noted some not-so-hot UT choices that never panned out, at least, for Texas: Eddie Jones (3),Deon Beasley(4),J'Marcos Webb(8),Jevan Sneed(11),Jared Norton (15), Phillip Payne (18), Vondrell McGee (21), Dustin Earnest (23), Brian Ellis (24)James Henry (26), and Buck Burnette (48).
At all schools, only 22 of the "Fab" 55 completed four seasons at the same university.
I suppose it could be an indictment of The AAS's ability to judge talent without shading their choices to fit UT's picks, or (more likely) an indictment of anybody's fans relying on "experts" to rate your school's picks.
As GP likes to say about them at this stage in the proceedings, is that they are all "paper tigers" until they prove it over time on the field. I'll trust him to know...after all he's twice as effective at spotting true talent than the vaunted UT staff, even according to their own hometown scribes.