Some recent ones:
- Tyler Matthews ... highly regarded 4* that did exactly nothing at TCU
- Foster Sawyer ... ditto, although he did at least get some game time
- Isaiah Chambers ... another high 4*, transfered out for family reasons
- Jordan Moore ... not a highly ranked recruit but this board loved him due to his athleticism. He was always on the verge of becoming our best player, seemed like
- Deshawn Raymond ... the highest ranked player in our 2015 class, struggled with injuries and learning the position. As far as I can recall, never played a meaningful down
- Ryan Parker actually signed with us twice, once as a high 3* out of HS and again as the #2 JUCO player in the country, was super talented, but never made it to campus
- Tyree Horton was going to be THE answer at LB and people were speculating on how to fill the gap when he left early for the NFL ... never made it to campus as far as I know, certainly never played
These are all from the past five years, and I could’ve easily added another few names that were widely discussed in Frog fandom from those classes (Vinny Ascolese, Mike Freeze, KeShawn Somerville, Ty Barrett, etc). There are always a lot of misses in recruiting.