• The KillerFrogs

Bye bye Cumbie...

T

tetonfrog

Active Member
Bruce Berry said:
Meacham was at the game.

From one of the 50,000 arm chair QB's....Cumbie is in over his head. That 4th down call officially ended it for me.
Click to expand...

And Meach was at the OSU game in 2015 when he had Kyle Hicks run the same DAMN play twice. It did not work then. It did not work now. It has never worked. It will never work.

But sure, bring back Meach and let's go through 2015 all over again. Come on! Either clean house or let it be.What is next? Bring back Pat Sullivan as co-OC?
 
T

tetonfrog

Active Member
Dusty said:
Collins was the best we had last year until he tore his throwing hand open. Collins should be the one starting.
Click to expand...

Wasn't Collins the starter last year at WV? When we suffered the worst loss in GP's history? Why would it change and how is he going to to stay healthy this year?
 
NewFrogFan

NewFrogFan

Full Member
Paxton Matthews said:
Fire Cumbie. And hire Doug Meacham our offense was amazing in 2014.
Click to expand...

If we are talking new blood, then get some REAL new blood. Who will admit they ever heard of Joe Brady before this year? The results are real. I thought there was discussion about issues with current staff and Meacham. Hell I would let Kenny Hill call plays or at least be a passing game coord. SC seems lost, his results prove it. After 3 games I once again dont know what the offensive theme is. I do know they 2 of the best RB’s in this decade on the same team and you almost never see them in the game together. (Have they ever)?
 
D

Dusty

Active Member
tetonfrog said:
Wasn't Collins the starter last year at WV? When we suffered the worst loss in GP's history? Why would it change and how is he going to to stay healthy this year?
Click to expand...

I don't recall if he started or not, but I remember him trying to play with a chunk of his palm stitched up on his throwing hand. He should not have been out there with that injury. Who can throw a ball with their hand like that.
 
M

Mean Purple

Active Member
Dusty said:
Yes sir, he has been practicing for for more than a month. He was on the sideline today sending in signals. This is getting old, Duggan is solid for a freshman, but he really needs to redshirt to give him time to develop.
Click to expand...
not just that, how many qb's are gonna come here in the future when they see many that did not develop or get playing time as they went on to upper class.

Collins was a way better choice than SR last year. Would love to see him get the reps and play … and not late in the game when it is getting too late.
 
D

Dusty

Active Member
Mean Purple said:
not just that, how many qb's are gonna come here in the future when they see many that did not develop or get playing time as they went on to upper class.

Collins was a way better choice than SR last year. Would love to see him get the reps and play … and not late in the game when it is getting too late.
Click to expand...

I agree completely. The offense came to life under Collins last year until he tore up his hand. I still don't understand why he was continuing to play after that injury. How could he hold and throw the ball if he couldn't grip it, still baffles me.
 
NewFrogFan

NewFrogFan

Full Member
Mean Purple said:
not just that, how many qb's are gonna come here in the future when they see many that did not develop or get playing time as they went on to upper class.

Collins was a way better choice than SR last year. Would love to see him get the reps and play … and not late in the game when it is getting too late.
Click to expand...

I was thinking he would come in today especially when they went down 2 TDs. Is he still hurt. Delton Anderson and Sewo ALL in the game and run the ball 80% of the time then throw to wide open TE’s!
 
D

Dusty

Active Member
NewFrogFan said:
I was thinking he would come in today especially when they went down 2 TDs. Is he still hurt. Delton Anderson and Sewo ALL in the game and run the ball 80% of the time then throw to wide open TE’s!
Click to expand...

I read Collins has been practicing for more than a month. He was on the sidelines today sending in signals. I really expected to see him come in as well. I would love to know who makes that decision, especially during a game. Is it the OC or HC. In any case, they really needed to pull the trigger long before the fourth quarter. But that is just my opinion.
 
NewFrogFan

NewFrogFan

Full Member
Dusty said:
I read Collins has been practicing for more than a month. He was on the sidelines today sending in signals. I really expected to see him come in as well. I would love to know who makes that decision, especially during a game. Is it the OC or HC. In any case, they really needed to pull the trigger long before the fourth quarter. But that is just my opinion.
Click to expand...

In the post game interview thread it was said that GP said it was SC call.
 
More Frogs the Better

More Frogs the Better

Full Member
There was a lot of bad to go around today but most of it started with the offense. Turnovers, fumbled snaps, ridiculously stupid play calls like the Sewo attempt to pass out of the Wild Frog and the last play, no separation by the receivers, no scheming Reagor into even being a factor in this game. It's always the same story and it's very tiresome to continually have one side of the ball that is not professionally coached, does not play with attention to detail, poorly develops its talent and operates from a scheme that is miles behind the better offenses in the conference.

I had very little benefit of the doubt left to give Cumbie starting this season and that is well gone at this point.
 
D

Dusty

Active Member
More Frogs the Better said:
There was a lot of bad to go around today but most of it started with the offense. Turnovers, fumbled snaps, ridiculously stupid play calls like the Sewo attempt to pass out of the Wild Frog and the last play, no separation by the receivers, no scheming Reagor into even being a factor in this game. It's always the same story and it's very tiresome to continually have one side of the ball that is not professionally coached, does not play with attention to detail, poorly develops its talent and operates from a scheme that is miles behind the better offenses in the conference.

I had very little benefit of the doubt left to give Cumbie starting this season and that is well gone at this point.
Click to expand...

I think that sums it up pretty well. I am still surprised at how little separation and how so little effort seems to be put out by our wide receivers. I am not sure if it is scheme or just coaching, but what ever it is, its just plain wrong.
 
Y

y2kFrog

Active Member
Mean Purple said:
GP had said there was a personality issue on staff. Well, one of them could design for wins. I think the better choice in personality left.
Click to expand...

Maybe the personality conflic
Dusty said:
I agree completely. The offense came to life under Collins last year until he tore up his hand. I still don't understand why he was continuing to play after that injury. How could he hold and throw the ball if he couldn't grip it, still baffles me.
Click to expand...

That was like 2 series.
 
AroundWorldFrog

AroundWorldFrog

Full Member
All goes back to 2013 when Lincoln Riley was begging for an OC job. And we hire Meach and Cumbie. Instead of the best offensive mind in college football.
 
Y

y2kFrog

Active Member
tetonfrog said:
And Meach was at the OSU game in 2015 when he had Kyle Hicks run the same DAMN play twice. It did not work then. It did not work now. It has never worked. It will never work.

But sure, bring back Meach and let's go through 2015 all over again. Come on! Either clean house or let it be.What is next? Bring back Pat Sullivan as co-OC?
Click to expand...

I think that was 2016, because 2015 was a really good offense.
 

Latest posts

Top