• The KillerFrogs
  • EECU the card that wins TCU championships

    EECU the card that wins TCU championships

We have single handedly taken the forward pass back to 1906

DaCrief

Active Member
Dumb argument. One of you is arguing just for he sake of argument and u know who you are. Thank you for your service, TB2. Thank you for beating Texas and Baylor. HOWEVER, There is a reason He was working at rb. His talent is apparent. But not as a full-time quarterback for this program. You don't need stats to see where there is promise and where the ceiling is fast approaching. He can help us win in other ways. But we need far more than he can offer at qb.
 

Pharm Frog

Full Member
Not sure how proficient the forward pass was in 1906 (or if it existed at all), but I suspect it was better than what we saw tonight (from both teams BTW) even if it hadn't been invented yet.
 

SwissArmyFrog

Active Member
Textbook knee jerk. Boykin is young and will get much better.

Can't bring myself to be confident in agreeing with you, here. If Boykin's passing skills (accuracy, etc...) had really improved measurably from his first game to now, I would be inclined to agree with you regarding his getting much better in the future. But he did not. He did get better as a runner, but not measurably as a passer. The coaches still will barely let him sniff at a pass over the middle.
 

Dogfrog

Active Member
NewFrog, we'll just have to agree to disagree. You can point to stats as your evidence (I hadn't added in tonight's stats to Boykin's totals, my apology) that there isn't much difference between the two and that we should remember that Andy wasn't great at first or whatnot but unfortunately, I choose to believe what my eyes tell me.

And for me, my eyes tell me that Andy NEVER had problems delivering a 4 yard swing pass and he never sidearmed his passes that I honestly remember at least. Now he threw some ints, that's for sure, but I'm fairly certain most on here would agree that they never questioned his ability to actually throw a forward pass, I know I didn't. My eyes tell me that Andy was a FAR better passer than Boykin may ever be although your stats may not indicate that to you.

You apparently choose to believe what you WANT to believe. NewFrog is right. If it makes you feel better to throw the freshman under th bus go for it. If Brown catches an easy TD or the refs call the safety or a couple of the dropped passes or interceptions get caught or Dawson doesnt muff the punt.....we wouldn't be having this conversation.
 

Frogs1983

Full Member
Textbook knee jerk. Boykin is young and will get much better.
Textbook knee jerk. Boykin is young and will get much better.
You absolutely sure about this? His throwing motion is a major flaw.It may be correctable,it may not be.None of us can say with 100% certainty either way right now.
I assume his running will improve once his injury(s) heal in the off season. Last night he was neither a running threat or passing threat the second half.Can't have this attribute in your QB and expect to win many games.
 

Chongo94

Active Member
You apparently choose to believe what you WANT to believe. NewFrog is right. If it makes you feel better to throw the freshman under th bus go for it. If Brown catches an easy TD or the refs call the safety or a couple of the dropped passes or interceptions get caught or Dawson doesnt muff the punt.....we wouldn't be having this conversation.

You are quite right. However, IF Boykin hits a wide open receiver in the first quarter we wouldn't be having it also. Problem is, he overthrew him, like usual. And I'm not throwing him under the bus as you term it, I'm just being a realist. The kid has heart, and takes a beating at times, and he definitely has talent, just as someone said earlier not as a full-time qb for this program.

As for stats, since y'all appear to value those above anything else, Dalton went 8-5 in his first season and Boykin went 3-6.
 
Top