• The KillerFrogs
  • EECU the card that wins TCU championships

    EECU the card that wins TCU championships

Patterson needs to call Kenny Hill NOW!

Ron Swanson

Full Member
I saw (a TCU starting qb) jump throwing the football on his first interception of the MSU game. that was not qb'ish. just flat out bad qb'ing. (Whoever it was) His footwork is less than desirable for a qb at H.S. level.

Agree, terrible mistake, but that's the kind of things that freshman do.... make bad decisions

100% fixable though
 

joejordan

Member
Great qb's make OL's look good. Likewise, great OL's make qb's look good. We had neither the back half of this season.
While I am confident that our OL will improve with reinforcements and returners, I am less confident in TB's abilities as a QB. There are too many issues with him that must be 'coached up and/or out' of his natural game.

PLUS - it is doing him no favors to be placed in a QB competition with the likes of Pachall and Mathews - prototype QB's with tremendous long-term QBing prospects. TB's athletic ability and general smarts will keep him in the hunt, vis-a-vis playing QB at TCU, but it will severely limit his future options in a League (NFL, CFL or AFL). AND, it could reduce the reps needed by Mathews to be able to take the reins in 2014.
 

BelushiBob

New Member
I saw a QB throw a TD that was dropped in the endzone too. Footwork is tough to have when you don't have a line that you trust.

Well I also saw that starting qb miss wide open receivers by about three yards. Ive seen better accuracy from 17 year old girls during the Dr. Pepper Scholarship Challenge.
 

cdsfrog

Active Member
Great qb's make OL's look good. Likewise, great OL's make qb's look good. We had neither the back half of this season.
While I am confident that our OL will improve with reinforcements and returners, I am less confident in TB's abilities as a QB. There are too many issues with him that must be 'coached up and/or out' of his natural game.

PLUS - it is doing him no favors to be placed in a QB competition with the likes of Pachall and Mathews - prototype QB's with tremendous long-term QBing prospects. TB's athletic ability and general smarts will keep him in the hunt, vis-a-vis playing QB at TCU, but it will severely limit his future options in a League (NFL, CFL or AFL). AND, it could reduce the reps needed by Mathews to be able to take the reins in 2014.

He is a project no doubt. So much to work on. Then again dalton was too......
 

cdsfrog

Active Member
Dalton was a classic prototype, and he's proving it now.

I watched an entire 2007 game. Bad footwork, poor accuracy, never looked past 2nd passing option, horrendous runner, turnover prone, horrible red zone protection, awful deep pass, bad 3rd down play and it goes on.
 

Get Your Frogs Up

Full Member
I'm no qb but it seems to me that a bum ankle would affect accuracy because planting and throwing is compromised. Throwing while running even moreso.

I agree and made that comment mostly in jest.

He definitely had a bad game and missed some easy throws on Saturday, I'm just not willing to throw away his career because of a couple bad games/throws his freshman year playing on a team with tons of injuries. It would be one thing if he didn't show flashes of greatness this year, but he did.

The second I saw Marcus Jackson play the position, I knew he was never going to be a big-time college QB, he just didn't have what it took. He just didn't have the arm.... he was an above average athlete playing the QB position (I said the same thing about Matt Brown during his first action).

I don't see that at all when I watch Boykin. I see a raw kid with all the physical tools necessary to become a great QB. I said the same thing about Dalton when people were ragging on him as a freshman.

I agree and think as he has time to improve his throwing mechanics his accuracy will improve. I'm not necessarily talking about making him throw textbook or drastically changing his natural arm angle, but just being consistent from throw to throw so he knows where the ball is going. I'm not sure if the inconsistency is due to the ankle/foot injury or sloppy mechanics or a little of both, but it seems like his arm slot and feet vary from throw to throw and just getting more consistent there will help a lot.

I think Boykin has the tools to be a great QB if he has the want to and puts in the time and effort.
 

arlington

Active Member
I have watched Kenny Hill..He makes throws a QB has to make...I have watched TB..He usually fails to complete the high percentage throws a QB has to make..One has terrific mechanics for a paser, one does not...
 

cdsfrog

Active Member
Agreed but not much better against way easier defenses. Crunch I'm not the biggest Boykin fan, just trying to be objective. Maybe I am overcompensating in that regard.
 

joejordan

Member
Agreed but not much better against way easier defenses. Crunch I'm not the biggest Boykin fan, just trying to be objective. Maybe I am overcompensating in that regard.

I didn't buy the whole 'major conference teams are WAY better than midmajor conference teams' argument before we joined one, and I don't buy it now. They do have more stars, bigger, faster (sometimes). But the MWC had quality teams, and the big 12 has not been known for great defenses.

I am a huge Boykin fan. Kid has heart, fearless and talented. QB ius not the position he should be playing, going forward. I understand why he did, but the situation far different, going forward.
 

cdsfrog

Active Member
I didn't buy the whole 'major conference teams are WAY better than midmajor conference teams' argument before we joined one, and I don't buy it now. They do have more stars, bigger, faster (sometimes). But the MWC had quality teams, and the big 12 has not been known for great defenses.

I am a huge Boykin fan. Kid has heart, fearless and talented. QB ius not the position he should be playing, going forward. I understand why he did, but the situation far different, going forward.

Good clarification. I love him as a tcu football player, not necessarily a tcu qb
 

Taco10

Active Member
I have watched Kenny Hill..He makes throws a QB has to make...I have watched TB..He usually fails to complete the high percentage throws a QB has to make..One has terrific mechanics for a paser, one does not...

Garrett Gilbert had great mechanics and was a great HS QB. Please stop comparing a HS player that playes for one of the best programs in the nation to a college QB. Boykin had great stats throwing the ball in high school too.
 
Top