• The KillerFrogs
  • EECU the card that wins TCU championships

    EECU the card that wins TCU championships

Patterson needs to call Kenny Hill NOW!

arlington

Active Member
Whatever. One qb accounted for 74 tds in 14 games in HS while another played QB more as an athlete at a non traditional power metroplex team. I have seen NOTHING in TB that shows he has the skillset in either arm or decisionmaking that will improve. He has gotten WORSE the more game film that he has accrued. Have you seen our game plans the past few weeks since Texas game? Its like even the coaches dont trust him to do anything either. We get a lead and try the prevent offense. We can trade offensive lines, coaches, whatever and Manziel will still be a very good player while TB will be a player who should be moved to rb
 

Salfrog

Tier 1
Has there ever been a worse miss for this staff than offering Boykin over Manziel? We probably could have used Johnny Football last night...just sayin.

I think/believe I heard there were some off field & attitude problems with Manziel that caused our coaches to back off from him during the recruiting process. I could be wrong on that, but I thought I had heard that from one of the coaches. He was hoping for a TCU offer, and would've jumped on it if we had of.
 

CountryFrog

Active Member
Whatever. One qb accounted for 74 tds in 14 games in HS while another played QB more as an athlete at a non traditional power metroplex team. I have seen NOTHING in TB that shows he has the skillset in either arm or decisionmaking that will improve. He has gotten WORSE the more game film that he has accrued. Have you seen our game plans the past few weeks since Texas game? Its like even the coaches dont trust him to do anything either. We get a lead and try the prevent offense. We can trade offensive lines, coaches, whatever and Manziel will still be a very good player while TB will be a player who should be moved to rb
Does TB have to be as good as Football for TCU to be successful? No. There's a large middle ground between a Heisman trophy winner and sucking. TB is somewhere in that middle ground and there's no reason to assume he won't get better as he gets older.
 
As frustrated I am with TB's progression, or lack thereof, I think we're being awfully hard on a freshman QB. These comparisons to Manziel are ridiculous. If he was the 10th freshman to win the Heisman that would be one thing but he was the first. TB had a lot to work on in the spring but let's not write him off just yet.
 

Ron Swanson

Full Member
I remember when Vince Young was inaccurate, had a weird throwing motion, and sucked as an underclassman.

And yes, I know Boykin isn't VY, but that's not the point. Frosh QBs often look in over their head and inaccurate
 

MacarthurTexas

Active Member
No coach/coaching staff gets it 100% correct with recruiting. That's why Coach P calls our new recruits ever year "paper tigers".

Also, before we judge Boykin against Manziel, let's get beyond their freshman seasons. Now Boykin earning a Heisman to match Johnny Football's this season may be a bit of a reach, but let's see who contributes more over the 4 full years to their team. I don't know if Boykin will eclipse Manziel, but it may be interesting to see how close their careers resemble one another (especially with Johnny Football having a less stellar O-Line and Boykin having a much better one than he enjoyed this season).

I think this is a great deal of wishful thinking. JM is incredible.
 

Nohitter

Member
Boykin will get better as a QB. The question is how much. The kid did well this year overall considering the pounding he took this year. But he did drop a big steaming pile last night.
 

PhillyFrog

Active Member
You would be better off not posting on football subjects. The kid has a ton of upside, and would have been a lot better this year if he'd had those AtM tackles in front of him.

The only thing keeping me from calling you an idiot is our shared love of TCU football.

Whatever. One qb accounted for 74 tds in 14 games in HS while another played QB more as an athlete at a non traditional power metroplex team. I have seen NOTHING in TB that shows he has the skillset in either arm or decisionmaking that will improve. He has gotten WORSE the more game film that he has accrued. Have you seen our game plans the past few weeks since Texas game? Its like even the coaches dont trust him to do anything either. We get a lead and try the prevent offense. We can trade offensive lines, coaches, whatever and Manziel will still be a very good player while TB will be a player who should be moved to rb
 

arlington

Active Member
Well our shared love of Frog football aside Phillyfrog, i dont share your belief that TB will get better at QB and it has nothing to do with JM. He has gotten worse nearly every week and its pretty obvious that the coaches are spoon feeding him the offense to keep him from being an absolute mess. Upside, great he has a strong arm, with absolutely no idea where to go with the ball and no touch on anything intermediate, the psses that this team will need to make consistently to compete in this league. My Manziel opinion has nothing to do with this years success, it is about evaluation. One kid piled up huge numbers THROWING the ball in a very good program. The other was more athlete than QB. Then said athlete gets on campus and everyone wonders why he seems to lack any QB instincts whatsoever.. With all the spread teams in the metroplex, how can we not have 3 or 4 guys on our roster capable of running the read option AND going through their progressions while making accurate passes all over the field? True our OLine isnt very good but how many sacks are due to his tendency to hold the ball forever? Failed project, lets move on
 

back_in_black

Moderators
Well our shared love of Frog football aside Phillyfrog, i dont share your belief that TB will get better at QB and it has nothing to do with JM.... Failed project, lets move on

Failed project? Wow! This a student athlete you're talking about. This is a guy that had no experience and horrible protection yet he lead is to road wins in hostile environments and gave us a chance to win nearly every game we played in. I guess you think he should be kicked to the curb because you are a the football expert and know there's no way he can ever improve. He had a bad bowl game for sure but even with that we still should've won. I think TB has earned just a little bit more respect than you appear willing to give (which in your case is basically none).
 
TB played very poorly in Tempe. The thing I see is that the game hasn't slowed down for him yet and he needs to get confidence in himself. He does have one of the worst LT in D-1 who misses every key block. I don't know if TB will be starting next year but I do know the hard work and dedication he has makes him a great Frog to me.
 

arlington

Active Member
Failed project as a person and a student athlete no.. I apologize for that reference thats definitely not what i intended to say. That being said as a QB this will never work out. Its obvious that he is an athlete playing QB. He went to a school with a history of average and was able to succeed due to being the best athlete on the team. Just run around and make plays. The game hasnt slowed down for him because he hasnt shown any basic skills that a qb needs to show and its highly unlikely that he ever will. Blame the line if you wish but CP wasnt a good runner and the line didnt get him killed and he was still able to put up decent numbers before his suspension. Outside of turnovers in the red zone our offense was humming to start the season. Now TB goes in, holds the ball too long, spraying passes all over the place, making poor decisions in the zone read, the one asset he should be able to master, coaches have no idea what to design as a game plan cuz they cant seem to come up with anything he can do on a consistent basis well..Whoopee, he beat Texas on the road..That team SUX and our coaches wouldnt even let him throw the ball, we went prevent offense the whole game much like we tried to do saturday night. We have got to get more qbs on this roster that are capable of running and throwing the ball downfield
 

Delmonico

Semi-Omnipotent Being
QB #1:
222 of 371 (59.8%), 2459 yds 10 TDs 11 int 118.5 rating


QB #2
167 of 292 (57.2%), 2054 yds 15 TDs 10 int 126.4 rating



One of them is Boykin's just completed Freshman yr. Who's the other one?
 

arlington

Active Member
No i didnt want Dalton benched despite his numbers. Stats can be made to reflect anything you want. who were the receivers on the team in Andys 1st year? Backs, linemen? What do the stats show about each players progress as the season wore on? I would venture to guess that Daltons numbers improved whereas Boykins has gotten worse, correct? Wasnt the Air Force game on ice a 4 INT day for Dalton that year like week 3? So perhaps in that one game he was so bad that it tilted his stats..Who knows. Hopefully in 4 years we can revisit this and i will gladly take the hits if i am wrong on TB. Regardless that doesnt change the fact that this program is painfully short on prospects at the single most important position in the B12 and that needs to be changed..
 
Top