• The KillerFrogs
  • EECU the card that wins TCU championships

    EECU the card that wins TCU championships

Offensive Coordinator

Kaiser

New Member
At some point, people will realize that having the best defense in the big 12 cannot overcome the worst offensive coordinator.

Apologizers can stop with their officials and other excuses, the playcalling is pathetic and predictable.

I Disagree. It's the players that left all those points on the field. We can't be creative on offense when we fail at the basics.
 

tcujsauce

Active Member
Yes, offense was ineffective this year. Yes, the play calling was suspect from time to time. But good God, give Anderson a break. This was his first season calling the plays, and he didn't have the QB he thought he was supposed to have for the whole season. Combine that with a fairly inexperienced line and losing your best rb, obviously the offense is going to struggle.


Whoever said this is worse than Shultz is a complete dip-s and should be tarred and feathered.
 

tcujsauce

Active Member
Also, it is true that our offense was extremely vanilla and predictable this year. But if you can't understand the reasoning behind it, then there's no hope for you.

Boykin performed admirably this season, but when you look at the whole picture, the kid is still very green, and just isn't that great right now. So the playbook has to be brought down to the QBs comprehension level. BIG lack of execution tonight. Besides a few nice long plays (including a closed-eyed prayer that wound up in the hands of Listenbee), it was either a terrible pass or a dropped ball.
 
Yes, offense was ineffective this year. Yes, the play calling was suspect from time to time. But good God, give Anderson a break. This was his first season calling the plays, and he didn't have the QB he thought he was supposed to have for the whole season. Combine that with a fairly inexperienced line and losing your best rb, obviously the offense is going to struggle.


Whoever said this is worse than Shultz is a complete dip-s and should be tarred and feathered.

I think it is worse than Schutlz and don't care if you consider me a dip-s or something worse. Schultz was bad, but most of the time he didn't have near this level of talent to work with. TCU is supposed to be, at this point, a top 25 or better program. We should have a top 25, or better, offensive coordinator. Please name one top 25, or even top 50, program who would hire our OC's. Hell, name a FCS program who would offer these guys a job based on the absolute crap they have put out there all year.

If this was an issue that started when TB took over, I would give you opinion some merit. However, it was obvious that they didn't know what the hell they were doing when they were running short-side options with an NFL quality QB. Go back and look at what we scored vs teams like VA compared to what some other rather awful teams put up.

They are bad, and we need to do better or we will be back next year with this same frustration. Period.
 

neutral observer

Active Member
Sorry, but they didn't have much to work with. Erratic QB play, injuries at RB, dropped passes by WRs, and green OTs. THe defense carried us this year.

We stunk in the second half and still nearly won the game. Too many lost opportunities! Interception and field goals.
 

Pharm Frog

Full Member
If this was an issue that started when TB took over, I would give you opinion some merit. However, it was obvious that they didn't know what the hell they were doing when they were running short-side options with an NFL quality QB. Go back and look at what we scored vs teams like VA compared to what some other rather awful teams put up.

And this is why I suggest in another thread that having Casey back in 2013 may not be the answer some folks are hoping for. One positive thing for me tonight was that the result may bring about a more critical review of where we stand and where we need to go than if the Sparty kick had sailed wide and we win by two. I think this may be true for both players and coaching staff (or at least I hope it's the case). My other hope is that there's not too many easy excuses (youth, injuries, suspensions, etc etc) to obscure the post mortem.
 

tcujsauce

Active Member
I think it is worse than Schutlz and don't care if you consider me a dip-s or something worse. Schultz was bad, but most of the time he didn't have near this level of talent to work with. TCU is supposed to be, at this point, a top 25 or better program. We should have a top 25, or better, offensive coordinator. Please name one top 25, or even top 50, program who would hire our OC's. Hell, name a FCS program who would offer these guys a job based on the absolute crap they have put out there all year.

If this was an issue that started when TB took over, I would give you opinion some merit. However, it was obvious that they didn't know what the hell they were doing when they were running short-side options with an NFL quality QB. Go back and look at what we scored vs teams like VA compared to what some other rather awful teams put up.

They are bad, and we need to do better or we will be back next year with this same frustration. Period.

Again, take a look at the situation. First year play caller and another first year OC, freshman QB who is extremely inconsistent and has a very low understanding of the offense compared to the QB that they OCs were preparing to work with ALL offseason/first 5 weeks, inexperienced and average at best OL, and best RB goes down early.


If we'd have had everyone we *should* have had all season, I'd be all on board with your line of thinking. But we didn't. So I'm not.
 

tcujsauce

Active Member
I might suggest that this scenario is not very likely even in some really fortunate years.

True, but I'm specifically pointing towards the loss of off of the most efficient passers in the country, and replacing him with a RSFreshman who throws side armed, has small hands, and isn't very accurate, or is at least wildly inconsistent.

That alone was the difference between our 7 win season and what very likely could've been a 9 or 10 win season.
 
Again, take a look at the situation. First year play caller and another first year OC, freshman QB who is extremely inconsistent and has a very low understanding of the offense compared to the QB that they OCs were preparing to work with ALL offseason/first 5 weeks, inexperienced and average at best OL, and best RB goes down early.


If we'd have had everyone we *should* have had all season, I'd be all on board with your line of thinking. But we didn't. So I'm not.

Well, first of all, why are we dealing with people who are unproven in the first place. Most of the time, other programs at our level do not just experiment with unproven people but demand a proven track record of success before you get to be the OC. So the first year part doesn't really change my thinking.

I agree that it is easy to allow the issue with the QB to obscure the issues. Granted, Bill Walsh might have trouble with what we are putting out there right now at that position. However, I still say go back to when CP, who is an elite talent, was playing the position and look at what we did vs what some other really average teams vs VA.

We have a chance next year to play with an elite QB, some seniors like Boyce, Maponga, and Verrett who are also pretty elite players, along with a lot of players who gained valuable experience this season. I would hate to waste it because we didn't see what was pretty obvious.
 

frogman

New Member
Unfortunately we have played and finished our season after Pachal left with a Lameduck QB.Boykin is done and should be doing something else.

Nothing wrong with our Offensive coordinators ,Fuentes got a better offer ,CGP need a replacement to add to our staff.

Our schemes are just fine .It is the execution that was horrible whole year .we need proper players to execute .we have not had a QB since Pachal had to leave,he will be Back,as we as Tyler will be ready to play.
Looking forward to next year ,spring training is few weeks away .Paha will be back 14th Jan.
 

ross

KMA
At some point, people will realize that having the best defense in the big 12 cannot overcome the worst offensive coordinator.

Apologizers can stop with their officials and other excuses, the playcalling is pathetic and predictable.

the first half of your statement is correct BUT your second sentence is partially misplaced
what you dont seem to understand is that the offensive play calling problems start higher than the co-coordinators
the offense play calling is directly controlled by coach P. they can't call plays he does not approve especially late in the game. until P changes his philosophy of "win by 1" we will always have this problem
P has to learn to trust his offense as much as he trust his defense and play to win the game instead of playing not to lose it
 

Froggy Style

Active Member
I Disagree. It's the players that left all those points on the field. We can't be creative on offense when we fail at the basics.
Wrong. When you're failing at the basics, you have to be creative. See fly sweeps vs OU. See two RB formation vs. Texas.

Posters on this board, including myself, called for those plays and formations all year, it only took all year to wait for them, and four weeks of waiting for the bowl game to mostly forget about them.
 

audiofrog

Member
Can't see why all the venom aimed at the OC's. first quarter, first pass of the night Boyce wide open a perfect pass may have been a TD, an accurate pass gains 15-18 yards and a first down. A pass thrown at his feet becomes a bad play call? Second set of downs Boyce WIDE open again and the pass is 10 yards over his head. Another bad play call? LaDarius Brown wide open in the end zone and he drops it. Bad play call? At the end of the game we need a first down Boykin hits White between the 8's and he drops it. I'm sure I'm missing a few but this one was on the players not the play calling.
I certainly would like to see the TE's used more often and with improved OL play and healthy RB's we may see a bit more wide open offense but yesterday's game was about the execution not the play calls
 

VA Froggie

Active Member
It didn't get a lot of play but I do wonder about Boykin's left foot, the way it was taped. It makes you wonder if it was hurting him when he would step into his throws. He was more inaccurate, by a bunch, than any time this year. His foot or pressure from MSU defense? He did run well on it though.
 

TopFrog

Lifelong Frog
At some point, people will realize that having the best defense in the big 12 cannot overcome the worst offensive coordinator.

Apologizers can stop with their officials and other excuses, the playcalling is pathetic and predictable.
Boykin had a terrible game with so many poor throws that were either too high, too low, behind or nowhere near a receiver. Cost us a lot of points and possession time.
 

Frog52

Active Member
After we tried to run our 185 pound freshman tailback between the tackles for the 4th time for no gain last night, I started to question the play-calling too. I try to be deferential to the coaches, but it gets frustrating when we do things that everyone in the stadium knows isn't going to work. If you want to run between the tackles against Michigan State, use a big back. Catalon and his speed would be great laterally but not so much between the tackles.

As it relates to anything being done about the offensive play calling, however, who do you think knows best which OCs out there have caused him the most trouble? That's right -- GP.

I don't know if GP hired Rusty and/or allowed Anderson to call the plays because he felt they made good calls against him in the past (Rusty was OC at SMU for a couple of years -- Anderson presumably coaches "against" GP in practice/scrimages every now and then), OR if he put those guys into the OC slots simply because he likes them as people. If it's solely the latter, then maybe he needs to replace at least one of them or supplement them with someone who he respects as an offensive playcaller because I think it's going to be tough to win a conference championship with these guys. Remember that we were good with Shultz, but we were great with Justin Fuente. I think the same is true here.
 

Froggy Style

Active Member
Boykin had a terrible game with so many poor throws that were either too high, too low, behind or nowhere near a receiver. Cost us a lot of points and possession time.
Agree. However, since he's been doing that all year, the handoff up the middle play should be used less, and swing passes, bootlegs, and fly sweeps should be used more.
 
Top