• The KillerFrogs
  • EECU the card that wins TCU championships

    EECU the card that wins TCU championships

NFL Mock Draft?

Hunt Together

Active Member
What good did it do the people I work with? They have MBA CPA and have to come ask a 24 year old how to do their damn job, or get him to do it for them. Even the boss who knows nothing can see their incompetence.

This actually proves everyone else's point. They may be incompetent, but their professional designations opened the door for them to be hired in a higher position in the company than you, despite your vast accounting knowledge after getting an undergrad that focused on "theoretical accounting." Imagine the doors that would open for someone with your intellectual capacity and a professional designation.
 

Atom

Full Member
And to Bonner's point, I am a CPA and when I took the exam it was paper based, 2 8 hour days at the Will Rogers Coliseum for 4 sections. 16 hours of test in 48 hours! At least for me, the only way I got through it was short-term memorization that for most of it I forgot within a year at most.

I can't tell you how many times now I get tax questions from people I meet and I have no clue what the answer is. Even though I passed the tax part of the exam 12 or so years ago, I haven't thought about it since.

I've always thought the CPA exam should be more like the Bar, whereas it should be more research based rather than memorization. So much of my job/real life is based on the ability to research rather than instantly know the right answer. Especially with how much the rules/laws change. It might be more like that with the computer based exam, but doubt it.

Over my career, I've worked with some very incompetent CPA's and some very competent non-CPA's who hadn't passed the exam for whatever reason. Its not an indicator of job performance.

But look at senior level accounting job openings, and most will say CPA required or at least CPA preferred. It opens doors.
 

60s Frog

Tier 1
And to Bonner's point, I am a CPA and when I took the exam it was paper based, 2 8 hour days at the Will Rogers Coliseum for 4 sections. 16 hours of test in 48 hours! At least for me, the only way I got through it was short-term memorization that for most of it I forgot within a year at most.

I can't tell you how many times now I get tax questions from people I meet and I have no clue what the answer is. Even though I passed the tax part of the exam 12 or so years ago, I haven't thought about it since.

I've always thought the CPA exam should be more like the Bar, whereas it should be more research based rather than memorization.

Let's not give the Bar Exam too much credit here . . . that was pretty much a "short term" learning experience as well.
 

VictoryLap

Full Member
And pretty soon I'll be their boss and will demote them to a bookkeeper in the corner with no windows.
Why the hell would you demote someone? If they are incompetent they need to be shown the door. Do you really expect an employee who is given less responsibility, less prestige, and less money to be a productive worker?
 

VictoryLap

Full Member
Another option not being discussed is doing an MBA program that allows you to work full time, which takes away the biggest opportunity costs of doing a traditional MBA which are foregone salary and work experience. I have 4 classes left to get my MBA (while still working full time) and overall I think it is a good investment so far. You certainly get out of it what you put into it though.
 
Why the hell would you demote someone? If they are incompetent they need to be shown the door. Do you really expect an employee who is given less responsibility, less prestige, and less money to be a productive worker?

By "demote" I meant in terms of title so that they would leave on their own.
 

frognutz

Active Member
Another option not being discussed is doing an MBA program that allows you to work full time, which takes away the biggest opportunity costs of doing a traditional MBA which are foregone salary and work experience. I have 4 classes left to get my MBA (while still working full time) and overall I think it is a good investment so far. You certainly get out of it what you put into it though.

Working, going to school, and pregnant wife. Been there. Woa! (add a 3 year old into the mix for added enjoyment)
 

An-Cap Frog

Member
Having an MBA does not make you better at say being an accountant. If anything, you are behind people your age because you have less work experience. You may get hired by a guy with an MBA or someone else who looks highly on it and you may get more money, but it does not mean you are better at what you do.

I second that...as a CPA, I have looked into various MBA programs...U of C and NW...I have not been convinced that obtaining a graduate degree would be worth the time at this moment. My CFO is getting an executive MBA right now, so maybe that might suit me better a couple years down the road.
 

Rolex

Active Member
Don't the majority of MAc students take Becker?

Probably - this is not exclusive to TCU, though. Most CPA candidates take a review course of some sort - you'd be foolish not to.

https://www.tsbpa.state.tx.us/php/fpl/unvcompare.php

I've attached a link with comparitive scores to other universities. If you look at the main testing windows for post-graduate students (July, August, September window) over the past three-five years you'll find TCU is pretty much tops in Texas with a ~70% pass rate. We're usually close to UT (whose accounting program is often mentioned as tops in the nation), and better than A&M, SMU, Baylor, Tech, and Houston (other schools who have a large # of candidates).
 
Top