Notre Dame is a better team than Miami according to the committee last Tuesday. Ranked #10 and Miami #12. So what changed? Neither team played this weekend. Greg McElroy concluded ND is a top five team - Most of the pundits would say ND is the better team. Vegas would too. As I suggested the other day, the committee might finagle an explanation to flip ND and Miami to save the ACC if Duke wins.
The last moment flip to make it about head-to-head is horse pucky - a three point loss on Miami’s home field on August 31; the first game of the season. Yards were about even and ND had a fumble and interception to no turnovers by Miami. The committee was aware of this week one head-to-head and this thus punctuates that the committee thinks ND is the better team, having dismissed that week one game - had all season! Until now.
Neither ND nor Miami had difficult schedules, both beating Pittsburgh easily enough but ND defeating #16 USC by ten points in the middle of the season.
The losses…
Besides the week one head-to-head, ND lost in week 2 to Texas A&M 41-40, a playoff team. They then won 10 straight to finish.
Miami lost to Louisville and SMU in the middle third of the season!
I thought the committee was suppose to pick the best at-large teams to fill in the bracket; not defer to the ACC campaign and maybe its ESPN TV partner.
Many feel ND would have been a contender for the Championship. I don't root for Notre Dame, but I just don't like the appearance of shenanigans here - credibility for the future. If Virginia had defeated Duke as was assumed, then the committee would not have finagled this change in the standings and I bet most agree - Virginia would have been in as the ACC rep, along with ND. Miami and James Madison would have been out.
Both the AP and Coaches poll still have ND ahead of Miami.
The CFP committee has blown its credibility, so we better go to sixteen teams and eliminate the damn byes. Vandy and Texas would have been good to see in this playoff too - I liked Vandy!