• The KillerFrogs

CFP 5+11 Model gains steam... is that good or bad for college football?

Limey Frog

Full Member
Last year's final Massey ratings, which is a composite of all computer rankings.....

1. Ohio State
2. Notre Dame
3. Oregon
4. Georgia
5. Texas
6. Penn State
7. Alabama
8. Tennessee
9. Ole Miss
10. Indiana
11. Michigan
12. LSU
13. BYU
14. South Carolina

15. Missouri
16. ASU
17. Florida
18. Iowa State
19. Clemson
20. Texas A&M

So you'd have been looking at OSU, Georgia, BYU, Clemson, and Boise State as the auto qualifiers and then the next 11, so the bolded teams in the CFP plus Boise State.

7 SEC
5 Big 10
1 Big 12
1 ACC
1 MWC
1 Notre Dame

Not sure people would be real thrilled with that outcome. I think it'd almost be a statistical impossibility that 3 Big 12 teams make it, unless they massively beefed up their OOC schedules and won those games.
In the next sentence after the one you bolded I wrote that it is conceivable the Big XII would get 3 or 4 teams in, not that it would happen every year. Or any year.
 

Dutch

T C U Froooogs
Dutch, respectfully, I hear you. All purple all the time here. But the Big 12 better start thinking like the SEC/Big, what’s good for the conference helps all teams, which helps TCU.
TCU will never win the big sausage contest with Texas and Ohio State. Very few in the XIl can do what TCU can do.
 

TopFrog

Lifelong Frog
Ohio State coach Ryan Day argues for Big Ten getting four automatic CFP bids

0_GettyImages-2212595575.jpg


Ohio State head coach Ryan Day is advocating for the Big Ten to receive at least four automatic bids in the College Football Playoff as discussions continue about expanding the playoff format to 16 teams. Day believes that the Big Ten's recent expansion to 18 teams, including strong programs like Oregon and Washington, justifies a greater representation in the CFP.

 

Limey Frog

Full Member
Ohio State coach Ryan Day argues for Big Ten getting four automatic CFP bids

0_GettyImages-2212595575.jpg


Ohio State head coach Ryan Day is advocating for the Big Ten to receive at least four automatic bids in the College Football Playoff as discussions continue about expanding the playoff format to 16 teams. Day believes that the Big Ten's recent expansion to 18 teams, including strong programs like Oregon and Washington, justifies a greater representation in the CFP.

Really it was so unfair of the rest of college football to force the Big Ten to destroy the Pac 12 and take four of its members. Why did we do that? The least we can do is make sure that 9-3 Iowa never misses the playoff in a year where they were unfairly scheduled to miss Ohio State, Michigan, Oregon, and Penn State but despite losing at Iowa State and Purdue and at home to USC did really teach some major lessons to those rascals Northwestern, Illinois, Rutgers, UCLA, Minnesota, Indiana, and Wisconsin.
 

Wexahu

Full Member
In the next sentence after the one you bolded I wrote that it is conceivable the Big XII would get 3 or 4 teams in, not that it would happen every year. Or any year.
I don’t think it’s conceivable, barring major changes in OOC scheduling philosophy (and Big 12 teams winning those games). The FCS school, G5 program, and middling P4 team type slate they all seem to fall in love with isn’t going to cut it if they expect more than one or maybe two teams to sneak in. Gonna need to play as many Big 10/SEC teams as you can, be willing to go on the road, and win those games. Not happening.
 

An-Cap Frog

Member
I don’t think it’s conceivable, barring major changes in OOC scheduling philosophy (and Big 12 teams winning those games). The FCS school, G5 program, and middling P4 team type slate they all seem to fall in love with isn’t going to cut it if they expect more than one or maybe two teams to sneak in. Gonna need to play as many Big 10/SEC teams as you can, be willing to go on the road, and win those games. Not happening.
What if the SEC had to play 9 conference games?
 

FroggleRock

Active Member
3x4+4 system. Top 3 teams in each conference are seeded how they finished. All 4 champs get a bye. 4 at-large bids with highest G5 getting the next highest seed and home field advantage in the 1st round. Then BIG and SEC will likely have the other at Alger spots anyways, so there’s your 4th team for those conferences.
 

Wexahu

Full Member
3x4+4 system. Top 3 teams in each conference are seeded how they finished. All 4 champs get a bye. 4 at-large bids with highest G5 getting the next highest seed and home field advantage in the 1st round. Then BIG and SEC will likely have the other at Alger spots anyways, so there’s your 4th team for those conferences.
3 Big 12 teams and 4 SEC teams in the playoff on an annual basis would be pretty laughable if the goal is to have the best teams competing.
 
Top