• The KillerFrogs
  • EECU the card that wins TCU championships

    EECU the card that wins TCU championships

Andy Reid: Please take Romo

joejordan

Member
OK - you have convinced me. Tony Romo is the QB that will take the Cowboys to the Superbowl. That is the goal, right? SuperBowl Romo, that will be his HOF nickname.

I am so glad I don't give a rats lass about pro football teams.
 

dkfrog

Active Member
Tony Football? ... i kid, i kid

But seriously...it is such an easy argument for the football dim-wit to lay blame at the feet of the quarterback. Yes, Romo makes some awful decisions at times, but there is so much more that goes into it than just that.
 

joejordan

Member
Tony Football? ... i kid, i kid

But seriously...it is such an easy argument for the football dim-wit to lay blame at the feet of the quarterback. Yes, Romo makes some awful decisions at times, but there is so much more that goes into it than just that.

It's also common for the lameman to fail to see when or why a situation is not working, yet grasp desperately for complex reasons beyond the one in his or her face.
 

Ron Swanson

Full Member
There are definitely better QBs than Romo in the NFL, but I think he is a little ways down the list when it comes to the Cowboy's problems. I think a team with a solid defense, solid OL, and solid running game can win a Super Bowl with Romo behind center.

The Cowboys should focus on improving all of that before they worry about QB, IMO. They could do a lot worse under center than Romo.

Ask any number of teams who would kill to have Romo right now. Not to mention, who are you gonna go get? Teams aren't just giving away their Super Bowl caliber QB's left and right.
 

joejordan

Member
There are definitely better QBs than Romo in the NFL, but I think he is a little ways down the list when it comes to the Cowboy's problems. I think a team with a solid defense, solid OL, and solid running game can win a Super Bowl with Romo behind center.

The Cowboys should focus on improving all of that before they worry about QB, IMO. They could do a lot worse under center than Romo.

Ask any number of teams who would kill to have Romo right now. Not to mention, who are you gonna go get? Teams aren't just giving away their Super Bowl caliber QB's left and right.

That dovetails with my original point. I couldn't care less about Romo the QB. I am looking at Romo the commodity. Much like Herschel the commodity. The Cowboys needed a whole lot, and all they had was a once-in-a-lifetime RB, who still had some value. They pulled off the trade of the century, which allowed the Cowboys to build a dynasty.

That is the type of thing I think they need to do now. Make it a 3-5 year plan, Get some O line, D line, perhaps a durable RB for a Romo, Witten trade. Giving up a lot, but if they can develop a good O- line, most serviceable QB's can get the ball to Dez, or hand off to quality RB. A couple of future picks would be good too.

They gotta do something, cuz it ain't working.
 

HToady

Full Member
Is it reasonable to assume that all people have differing levels of competency that can't be exceeded regardles of experience? Can this be because of upbringing, education, physical limitations?

Has a guy from Harvard a better chance at becoming a CEO, then a guy from Texas Tech?

We keep hearing that Romo is a "work in progress". Isn't it possible that he has reached his maximum level. He didn't have the lifetime experiences of playing in a Big Time college program, and performing under stress. So when stress comes he makes bad decisions. I don't think with out the eperiences under stress he will ever be able to change. You can't blame OL, coaching, or anything else on bad decisions.

He is who we thought he was.......
 

Ron Swanson

Full Member
That dovetails with my original point. I couldn't care less about Romo the QB. I am looking at Romo the commodity. Much like Herschel the commodity. The Cowboys needed a whole lot, and all they had was a once-in-a-lifetime RB, who still had some value. They pulled off the trade of the century, which allowed the Cowboys to build a dynasty.

That is the type of thing I think they need to do now. Make it a 3-5 year plan, Get some O line, D line, perhaps a durable RB for a Romo, Witten trade. Giving up a lot, but if they can develop a good O- line, most serviceable QB's can get the ball to Dez, or hand off to quality RB. A couple of future picks would be good too.

They gotta do something, cuz it ain't working.

Not a bad idea. I wonder what the market for him is?

Trade him for a bunch of picks (to a team that has a solid core but a crappy QB), then sign an experienced veteran QB to help hold the team together for a couple years, then either draft or trade for a potential star QB. The Texans got Matt Schaub from the Falcons for two 2nd rounders (because they had Vick), which was a great investment for us. Obviously, Matt's no world-beater, but at least he's serviceable.
 

Ron Swanson

Full Member
Is it reasonable to assume that all people have differing levels of competency that can't be exceeded regardles of experience? Can this be because of upbringing, education, physical limitations?

Has a guy from Harvard a better chance at becoming a CEO, then a guy from Texas Tech?

We keep hearing that Romo is a "work in progress". Isn't it possible that he has reached his maximum level. He didn't have the lifetime experiences of playing in a Big Time college program, and performing under stress. So when stress comes he makes bad decisions. I don't think with out the eperiences under stress he will ever be able to change. You can't blame OL, coaching, or anything else on bad decisions.

He is who we thought he was.......

Romo has been in the league for like 6-7 years, he's not really a work in progress at this point. Yeah, he can still refine his game and learn to make better decisions, but I don't think anyone is expecting wholesale changes in his game at this point. He's 32
 

joejordan

Member
Not a bad idea. I wonder what the market for him is?

Trade him for a bunch of picks (to a team that has a solid core but a crappy QB), then sign an experienced veteran QB to help hold the team together for a couple years, then either draft or trade for a potential star QB. The Texans got Matt Schaub from the Falcons for two 2nd rounders (because they had Vick), which was a great investment for us. Obviously, Matt's no world-beater, but at least he's serviceable.
e
Exactly. It takes vision beyond the emotion of defending Romo's performance.

Imagine next season. Here come the Cowboys, with Tony Romo at the reins. Yee Haw.
 

dkfrog

Active Member
That dovetails with my original point. I couldn't care less about Romo the QB. I am looking at Romo the commodity. Much like Herschel the commodity. The Cowboys needed a whole lot, and all they had was a once-in-a-lifetime RB, who still had some value. They pulled off the trade of the century, which allowed the Cowboys to build a dynasty.

That is the type of thing I think they need to do now. Make it a 3-5 year plan, Get some O line, D line, perhaps a durable RB for a Romo, Witten trade. Giving up a lot, but if they can develop a good O- line, most serviceable QB's can get the ball to Dez, or hand off to quality RB. A couple of future picks would be good too.

They gotta do something, cuz it ain't working.

Is a trade like that still possible in the salary cap era. I have a good working knowledge of most of the NBA issues related to player for pick trades, but I have no idea where to start with an NFL player for picks trade. Would they have to trade him to a team that could absorb his salary under the cap?
 

Young and Horned

Active Member
e
Exactly. It takes vision beyond the emotion of defending Romo's performance.

Imagine next season. Here come the Cowboys, with Tony Romo at the reins. Yee Haw.

Agree,

Here come the Cowboys with Vince Young at the reins. Is better.

Here come the Cowboys with Matt Flynn at the reins. Is also better.

Here come the Cowboys with Michael Vick at the reins. Is also better.

Here come the Cowboys with Matt Cassel at the reins. Is also better.

Here come the Cowboys with Kyle Orton at the reins. Is also better.

Here come the Cowboys with Kolb at the reins. Is also better.

Point is, there is nothing else out there that is better. I hate the Cowboys, but Romo is a good QB who plays with a supremely sub-par OL. People want to defend TB and blame the OL, but then blame Romo.
 

jake102

Active Member
Point is, there is nothing else out there that is better. I hate the Cowboys, but Romo is a good QB who plays with a supremely sub-par OL. People want to defend TB and blame the OL, but then blame Romo.

It's not the play to play performance Romo puts out that is disappointing, it's the idiotic plays he makes in crucial situations. I'm pretty sure his subpar OLine didn't force him to make a terrible decision and pass at the end of the game against the Redskins. That was all Romo.

That being said, you are right, there isn't really anybody better and I don't think there is anybody in the draft who will be better.
 
Top