You are, of course, correct. However, I submit that a kid who has 1.) Abandoned his H.S. team, and 2.) Abandoned his College team, really doesn't seem to display that "team player" attitude terribly well. Whatever his physical gifts, his attitude and locker-room-cancer potential are vast.
There are a host of good QB candidates out there. He was #1 last year. Who is #1 this year? Next year? Who is #2 in those classes, and by how much? What are the metrics by which this lofty status was achieved, and are there other kids who are a little more (evidently) reliable out there to be found?