3 out of last 4 years have been riddled/sabotaged with poor QB play. The notion (sometimes floating around this board) that Cumbie is some QB guru that will warp this kid into shape is misguided and just not substantiated with any recent evidence.
I believe the evidence is there. Elevated TB and KH. Kohlhausen was ready to go in a tough spot and situation. Collins was solid. Injuries kept from seeing a final grade on him.
SR didn’t put in the work and didn’t seem to learn. His teammates lost confidence in him. His parents were enablers. Cumbie couldn’t force SR to give his best and work hard. SC could have benched him sooner. I do fault Cumbie for that.
JR, what can you say? Devastating injury at the beginning of his HS senior season. Was out of FB competition for over three years. That is hard to make up at the QB position. He needs reps but hard to do others are outperforming. Catch 22 for JR. I hope he regains his form at UNLV and tears it up. Hopefully, the staff out there will be patient with him.
Max was a true freshman and was solid as a true freshman playing behind a poor OL. He was good and bad, but that would seeme to be expected from most true freshman at the QB spot. He works hard and is a winner. That was evident on how he played and carried himself. His best days are ahead of him.
So, you think some of us are delusional in that we think SC is a good QB coach. Interesting, I believe the evidence suggests SC is a good coach, more that the side you are coming from so far.