I hate to bring this back up again, but do you really honestly think that if TCU had lost to Minnesota in 2014 but then went on to finish 12-1 with a 59 point win in the Big 12 championship game you'd have been ok with being left out of the playoffs? Because by saying TCU deserved to be in over OSU, that is what you are saying. And I call total BS on that. If we had OSU's resume and were left out, we might've started a riot. I can tell you right now that there is no freaking way on earth you would've accepted that outcome.
So they really are making decisions based on results on the field, you just refuse to accept it.
You are so wrong in so many ways. You just buy in to the committee approach. You really don't like the do it on the field approach. Baylor even deserved to be picked over ohio st that year. They only had the 1 upset loss to WV on the road. However they are a small private school with a much smaller alumni base than ohio state. I hate Baylor by the way. The only way to at least dilute this bias is to go to an 8 team playoff.